We would like to recognize members of the PC-committee for contributions that have improved the reviewing/selection process and helped to make ECAI 2023 “bigger and better”
 
The “Early Bird” award  is given to Reviewers who submitted at least 4 reviews and who started working on all of their reviews at least ten days before the deadline.  The following 87 reviewers (out of over 700 Reviewers with at least 4 reviews) received this award. 

Alaa Daoud
Philippe Giabbanelli
Fabrizio Riguzzi
Peter Stuckey
Esther Galbrun
Robin Cohen
Fabien Gandon
Jesús Giráldez-Cru
Giuseppe Vizzari
Witold Dzwinel
Francesco Ricci
Junfeng Wen
Özgür Özçep
Lihi Dery
Xin-Chun Li
Loris Nanni
Chuanxing Geng
Piyawat Lertvittayakumjorn
Katrien Beuls
Hideitsu Hino
Da-Wei Zhou
Corrado Mencar
Paolo Turrini
Silja Renooij
Mauro Vallati
Gilberto Marcon dos Santos
David Losada
Tomas Kliegr
Zeynep G. Saribatur
Guglielmo Gemignani
Vittorio Bilò
Luis Quesada
Bart Craenen
Zoi Terzopoulou
Enzo Veltri
Peter Nightingale
Oscar Cordón García
Lars Kotthoff
Nir Oren
Ahad N. Zehmakan
Stefan Ellmauthaler
Changkun Jiang
Sébastien Ferré
Valerio Restocchi
Jin-Hui Wu
Amparo Alonso-Betanzos
Timothy van Bremen
Alban Grastien
Roberto Asín
Yan Yan
Ke Zhu
Jing Wu
Gloria Bordogna
Aitor García-Pablos
Dinkar Juyal
Runxue Bao
Luchen Li
Sotiris Batsakis
Kai Zhou
Pedro Larranaga
Adrien CHAN-HON-TONG
Ruwang Jiao
Yaoxin Wu
Peng Tan
Pietro Totis
Fernando Bobillo
Athanasios Aris Panagopoulos
Aritz Pérez
Petr Berka
Chiaki Sakama
Cecilio Angulo
Ziqi Zhang
Graçaliz Dimuro
Luca Rossetto
Yanhao Wang
Umberto Straccia
Mohammad Al-Zinati
Michael Thomazo
Helen Harman
Bruno Yun
Ulises Cortes
Zheng Zhang
Andreas Wichert
Edy Portmann
Luca Oneto
Aleksander Byrski

The “Discussion Master” award is given to Reviewers who submitted at least 4 reviews and who participated at least 7 times in discussions over their papers.  The following 83 reviewers (out of over 700 Reviewers with at least 4 reviews) received this award.  
 
Florian Pommerening
Stepan Kochemazov
Pierre Marquis
Adam Wyner
Grégory Bonnet
Sarah Winkler
Roberta Calegari
Yoni Zohar
Edith Hemaspaandra
Ingo Pill
Peter Stuckey
Tiep Le
Jan Paralic
Tiago de Lima
Gauvain Bourgne
Yuan Yao
Alain Dutech
Michael Felsberg
Andrzej Kaczmarczyk
Daniela Briola
Jennifer Renoux
Eva Onaindia
Nic Wilson
Umang Bhaskar
Diedrich Wolter
Maike Schwammberger
Swaprava Nath
François Durand
Jordi Coll Caballero
Vasco Manquinho
Arianna Novaro
Nardine Osman
Alexandre Niveau
Stéphanie Roussel
Sylwia Polberg
Dimitrios Diochnos
Paolo Turrini
Ronald de Haan
Viviana Mascardi
Liangda Fang
Miroslav Kulich
Silja Renooij
Franz Baader
Tommaso Zoppi
Xuan Zhu
Mauro Vallati
Zeynep Kiziltan
Laurent Perrussel
Johannes Wallner
Esteban Guerrero
Dengdi Sun
Francesco Belardinelli
Marina De Vos
Dariusz Krol
Mathijs de Weerdt
Ringo Baumann
Mengwei Xu
Harko Verhagen
Gilberto Marcon dos Santos
David Losada
Tomas Kliegr
Matthias Thimm
Sebastian Cygert
Harmen de Weerd
Alessandro Ricci
Hang Ma
Dominique Longin
Francesco Calimeri
Giuseppe Perelli
Patricia Everaere
Pradeep Murukannaiah
Catalin Dima
Chenhao Wang
Kewen Wang
Paul Bethe
Alvaro Torralba
Javier Alvez
Zhengxin Huang
Daniel Le Berre
Matteo Baldoni
Maria Gini
Ulises Cortes

The “Quality Champion” award  is given to Reviewers who 1) submitted at least 4 reviews, 2) at least one review was rated as “exceeding expectations” and no review was rated “below expectation” by the relevant Meta Reviewer. The following 58 reviewers (out of over 700 Reviewers with at least 4 reviews) received this award.

Marc Serramia
Nirav Ajmeri
Ron Petrick
Florian Pommerening
Peter Stuckey
Edith Hemaspaandra
Stepan Kochemazov
Alberto Bugarín-Diz
Jennifer Renoux
Vito Walter Anelli
Gauvain Bourgne
David Sarne
Simon Ståhlberg
Sarah Winkler
Roberta Calegari
Leandro Soriano Marcolino
Adam Wyner
Marcel Steinmetz
Salome Eriksson
Pierre Marquis
Krzysztof Krawiec
Davide Dell'Anna
Grégory Bonnet
Michael Felsberg
alaa daoud
Tobias Huber
Yoni Zohar
Francois Schwarzentruber
Ramon Fraga Pereira
Esther Galbrun
Changhui Hu
Anagha Kulkarni
Jan Paralic
Masood Feyzbakhsh Rankooh
Ingo Pill
Tiago de Lima
Noura FACI
Sergio Alvarez-Napagao
Muhammad Rahman
Marina Zanella
Jamal Bentahar
Philippe Giabbanelli
mattia d'emidio
Tiep Le
Giovanni Beltrame
Paul Rauwolf
Laurent Gourvès
Manuel Montes-y-Gomez
Jorge Diez
Fabrizio Riguzzi
Marcos Cramer
Stefan Borgwardt
Julian Padget
Christian Strasser
Deshendran Moodley
Jan Maly
Mingfei Sun 

The “Call to Arms” award is given to authors in the volunteer pool who were asked to complete at least one review three days before the deadline. The following 152 authors received this award:

Carson Leung
Giang Nguyen
Frédéric Piedboeuf
Lv Peizhuo
Baokui Li
Rongguang Ye
Heng-yang Lu
Shunyu Liu
Lin Wang
Wolfgang Maass
Georgios Papasotiropoulos
Pawel Zawistowski
Jipeng Qiang
Mauro Barni
Ondřej Kubíček
Helena Balabin
Rui He
Nicola Franco
Hongzhan Lin
Shufang Zhu
Jiangming Liu
Yihong Dong
Peiyao Hua
Weijian Ma
Gang Ma
Erika Duriakova
yuwei Wang
Tim Fischer
Gang Ma
Yang Bai
Gianluca Moro
Yiming Hei
Adrian Horzyk
Junwei Su
Aurélien Delage
Tianjun Wu
Jingqing Ruan
Luyuan Xie
Xiankun Yan
ShaoXiong Zhang
Daxin Liu
Shimon Komarovsky
Francesco Leofante
Ali Beikmohammadi
Nicholas Zerbel
Xueyao Sun
Yifei Wang
Xueyao Sun
Guido Sciavicco
jie zhu
Yongsheng Mei
Bingsen Xue
Yongli Mou
Qizhi Wan
Marek Kretowski
Hongye Zhu
Amit Kumar Jaiswal
Ruifan Li
Florian Ahrens
Yang Bai
Dong Zhang
Hui Liu
Kyungsu Kim
Ding Qiuyu
Thomas Weisswange
Radosław Pytlak
Nada Sharaf
Diarmuid O'Reilly-Morgan
Jian Xu
Szymon Olewniczak
Da Ren
Misgina Tsighe Hagos
Ruobing Jiang
Tanmay Ambadkar
Vitaliy Yakovyna
Yi Chen
Tieke He
Yuanqiu Liu
Zhiyue Wang
Cheng Gong
sonia Djebali
Maryam Rostamigiv
Xueyi Liu
Munyque Mittelmann
Liang Duan
Gerry Dunda
Khanh Ngo Huu
Yuxiang Wang
Katarzyna Filus
Saar Cohen
Minglai Shao
Boqian Wu
Francesco Fuggitti
Md Fahim Sikder
Chan-Hee Lee
Mingjia Shi
Yunye Zhang
Ahmad Chaddad
Qi Li
David Broneske
Derui Zhu
Mitisha Gaur
Ying Zhu
Adam Pardyl
Tyler King
Yi Liu
Preston Robinette
Bo Huang
Mantas Simkus
Xiaoge Deng
Luìs Cruz-Filipe
Xiaolei Diao
Elias Tragos
Zhixin Li
Jingying Gao
Mingyue Zhang
Yunpeng Li
Christine Sinoquet
Atsuhiro Takasu
Malgorzata Kretowska
Krzysztof Slot
Chao Ma
Xiangyu Peng
Robbert Reijnen
Haonan Jiang
Dimitris Michailidis
Feifei Dai
Xiaoyan Gu
Marcin Mazur
Mihai Suciu
David Corsar
Wei Xiang
Jonathan Balloch
Tian-Zhu Xiang
Geng Tu
Hanfei Yu
Badran Raddaoui
Gamage Kokila Kasuni Perera
Zhenghan Chen
Pouya Ghiasnezhad omran
Songtuan Lin
Bohan Li
Maximilian Schmidt
Yuanyang Zhu
Shqiponja Ahmetaj
Xiaowei Xu
Xue Gu
Timothy Parker
Shanshan Huang
Qi Li
Rihab Balti
Kritesh Rauniyar 

The “Esteemed Evaluator” award  is given to Meta Reviewers who rated all of their reviews.  The following 35 Meta Reviewers (out of over 700 Reviewers with at least 4 reviews) received this award: 

Juan Nieves
Maria Polukarov
Konstantin Yakovlev
Hau Chan
Andreas Theodorou
Ana Ozaki
Fabio Patrizi
Alexey Ignatiev
Francesco Ricca
Abeer Dyoub
Yongmei Liu
Ulle Endriss
Joerg Rothe
Tristan Cazenave
Martin Gebser
Domenico Bloisi
Valentin Robu
Pinar Yolum
Luca Iocchi
Ondřej Kuželka
Bruno Zanuttini
Frank Wolter
Matteo Luperto
Adrian Pearce
Yanan Sun
Quan Li
Ines Lynce
Miquel Ramirez
Rustam Galimullin
Teng Zhang
Ken Brown
Jakub Kowalski
Ronald Poppe
Carlos Mencia
Carsten Lutz

The “Personally commended” award is given to Program Committee members who were personally commended by their peers for their efforts. The following 27 Program Committee members received this award: